When people look back on the history of the sitcom, they get to Seinfeld and start using language reminiscent of the final days the Roman Empire. ("The world was never the same after Seinfeldius the Great. After his fall, TV was left vulnerable to those bands of marauding savages known as Reality Shows.")
Most TV fans agree that Seinfeld was the best television comedy of the 90s (and some would say of all time). But there seems to be a disturbing trend of saying that it was the last best sitcom-- that the sitcom as we knew it died as the camera slowly moved away from Jerry and the gang in their shared jail cell, talking about nothing.
This list aims to prove such pessimism wrong. Although it may have taken a while, television comedy has begun to find footing again after Seinfeld ended its run. In the beginning of the post-yada yada era, comedy had been reborn in a new form and a new venue. This new breed of sitcom is usually more at home on cable or the Internet instead of the networks, and the shows don't have a problem with dispensing of laugh tracks or a "live studio audience."
More recently, reality and drama have still been the ratings behemoths of the moment, and a lot of these great shows had to learn that the hard way (example: how FOX treated Arrested Development). But that was a few years ago. These days, network TV's attitude toward good comedy is starting to thaw. Just look at NBC, who just recently started touting their Thursday night comedy block again. Comedy is still alive and starting to gain a new following. Rising from Seinfeld's ashes, here are the ones we have to thank.
10. Malcolm in the Middle (FOX) - Created on the heels of The Simpsons' mid-life success of the mid-to-late 90s (see #2), Malcolm in the Middle looked a bit suspicious at first. Another FOX sitcom about a dysfunctional family trying to keep it all together? But Malcolm deserves some credit for its more realistic portrayal of the typical lower-middle class family. Although the best episodes always had a surreal quality to them, the characters stayed as real as the dead grass on their toy-strewn front lawn. (How Jane Kaczmarek never won an Emmy for playing Lois is beyond us.) Malcolm's premise wasn't anything new, but the way it was able to stay funny without looking like a parody of Roseanne certainly was.
9. Curb Your Enthusiasm (HBO) - It's confusing. The more you watch Curb Your Enthusiasm, the more you learn about Larry David. The more you learn about Larry David, the more you realize that he's an incompetent, self-loathing loser. The more you realize that he's an incompetent, self-loathing loser, the more you realize that Seinfeld's success had to have been a serendipitous fluke. But then you remember that watching Curb Your Enthusiasm is what made you think that in the first place, and you realize that Seinfeld couldn't have been a fluke. And although you hate yourself for thinking it, you wish everyone could be more like Larry David.
8. Flight of the Concords (HBO) - Some forms of comedy just don't translate that well into a half-hour TV show, and before Flight of the Concords came along, folk parody seemed pretty safe on that list. Concords works because it manages to take what made Jemaine and Bret successful as an act (deadpan delivery of silly kiwi folk songs) and combine it with the funniest supporting cast on TV. The band's manager Murray ranks up with The Office's David Brent as the worst friend a TV protagonist could have. And props to Kristen Schaal for pulling off the most endearing portrayal of an obsessed stalker/fan-club president we've ever seen. The result is a one-of-a-kind half-hour sitcom musical that only "New Zealand's fourth most popular folk parody duo" could pull off.
7. Yacht Rock (Channel101.com) - Channel101.com is a place where users create their own pilots of short TV shows and submit them to an audience vote. If the show gets enough votes, they live to make more episodes. Channel101's formula seems to have worked pretty well beyond just the Website, helping launch the "legitimate" TV careers of Adult Swim's Tim and Eric, SNL's Lonely Island crew and Community creator Dan Harmon. In a time when TV is struggling to pin down just what the coveted high school/college demographic likes, Channel101 seems to have found the most democratic way of finding out.
The real stars of this InterNetwork, though, are JD Ryznar and the gang, who are responsible for some of the highest-quality low quality on there. Their masterwork is Yacht Rock, a series that lasted a whopping 10 episodes before it was cancelled. That's like 20 seasons in Channel101 time. Yacht Rock acts as a mock Behind the Music that chronicles the origins, intrigues and bitter politics behind the careers of Michael McDonald, Kenny Loggins, Toto, Hall and Oates and other titans of smooth FM rock from the late 70s to mid 80s, which, thanks to this show and a little help from Jimmy Fallon, is simply known as "yacht rock."
Don't be fooled by the bad wigs and sub-par acting, the fellas from Yacht Rock know how comedy works, and they manage to weave a perfect mix of drama, rock nerd trivia and late night punchlines into episodes that never go over five minutes. VH1 did try to get Ryznar and other 101 stars to work their magic on the tube with Acceptable.TV, which followed the exact same premise as Channel101, but the VH1 show didn't last long; proof that sometimes, the best TV shouldn't be on TV at all.
6. The Office (NBC) - If there are still a few Ricky Gervais purists out there who insist that the American Office will never be what the British one was, and for that reason won't watch it, let's get a few things straightened out.
Now, you're half right: the American version will never be what the British Office was, but that's no reason to boycott Dunder Mifflin in the defence (notice that British "c" there?) of Wernham Hogg. What makes NBC's The Office so great is the fact that it won't ever be what the BBC version was.
Sure, the essentials from the original are still there: the aloof, socially incompetent boss; the unquestioning obedience of the number 2; and the romantic chemistry between the angelic receptionist and the likable paper salesman. But it's the differences that make American Office special.
Most of the credit goes to Steve Carell's performance as the boss, Michael Scott. Before he was cast, Carell had never seen an episode of the BBC version, and he used that to his advantage. His interpretation is purer and free from the clutter of trying to simply portray an American David Brent.
Michael Scott is still a disaster of a boss, but in his own way. Where David Brent's social implosions usually come from his inability to hide his own hypocrisies (acting morally disgusted at a dirty picture being sent around the office until he found out it was his pal who did it), Michael Scott's are usually because of his naive, almost childlike, view of the world (expecting the middle-aged, overweight and sole black guy in the office to be good at basketball).
NBC's The Office isn't the only offspring of the BBC hit; there are other versions in France, Germany and Canada. But the American version is one child that has managed come of age and make its own way in the world.
5. 30 Rock (NBC) - Write what you know. Tina Fey seemed to follow that axiom when the former Saturday Night Live head writer created this gem about a female protagonist trying to keep her professional and personal sanity in tact while working as a head writer for a NBC sketch comedy show in 30 Rockefeller Center. But let's not get too hung up on the seemingly-autobiographical premise.
When we say that Tina Fey writes what she knows, what we really mean is sketch comedy. 30 Rock certainly has a few plot twists here and there, but like any good sketch, the story relies on bizarre-yet-relevant characters and not the other way around. As a result, we get to see Tracy Jordan spew wisdom like an MC who escaped from a mental institution. We get to hear Jack Donaghy's crisp voice pontificating his cynical diatribes, comfortable in the fact that he's a neocon who doesn't have to run for office. And, while we do root for Liz Lemon and her search for love and personal fulfillment, we still laugh instead of cry when she rips open another bag of Sabor de Soledad.
If you're looking for another Jim and Pam love story, you should have tuned in a half-hour earlier. All you'll get here is a glimpse into one of the best comedic minds of our time.
4. South Park (Comedy Central) - Not to get too nerdy on everybody, but comedy is important. It uses laughter to talk about things we normally wouldn't touch. When comedy is able to use its craft to make people think about the state of society and question some of our bizarre norms, it can then use the lofty title of satire. We usually bring up dusty old names like Juvenal or Mark Twain when we discuss satire, but we submit here that the best political satire on our current culture is in the form of the poorly animated, foul-mouthed fourth-graders from South Park. In its late night time slot on basic cable, this show is able to get away with a lot, and there seems to be no limit to what it won't try. Its critics are right for the most part: it's crude, offensive and takes a lot of liberties with bathroom humor. And no, it can't say that all of its victims have it coming. (Has anyone gotten on YouTube demanding that they leave Sarah Jessica Parker alone yet?) But at its best, it's also smart, genuine and honest -- sometimes painfully so. One week, you'll be laughing at those crazy Scientologists, and the next week it suddenly isn't so funny when it's your own church being lampooned. One minute you'll praise them, thinking that it's high time someone stuck it to those Democrats, and the next minute you're balking at a jab on Republicans. The point is that South Park has no loyalties or sacred cows. Going into an episode is like going into that log ride at Disneyland: you will get wet. But you'll also laugh your head off.
3. Arrested Development (FOX) - It's refreshing when TV admits that family dysfunction isn't reserved for the poor only, and that it doesn't end just because everyone is an adult. This short-lived "story about a wealthy family who lost everything and the son who had no choice but to keep them all together" quickly became a cult favorite after its premiere in 2003. Arrested Development is full of whip-smart writing and quick gags that require a little more attention to detail than most sitcoms, but lead to a satisfying payoff in just about every episode. On the surface, AD certainly looked like it had it all: crisp dialogue, surprisingly intricate plot lines for a 30-minute comedy, the powerful bankrolling capacities of producers Ron Howard and Brian Grazer, and the best TV ensemble cast of its time. Unfortunately, what it didn't have was its network's support, and it was unceremoniously dumped after three seasons. Worse, FOX replaced it with a Pamela Andersen vehicle called Stacked, favoring big boobies over smart, well-earned laughs.
While there are rumors of an Arrested Development movie in the works, we're fine spending our days off watching and re-watching those three glorious seasons on DVD, and always finding a surprised Easter egg of comedic gold no matter how many AD marathons it's been. And isn't that just good television?
2. The Simpsons (FOX) - Yes, technically, The Simpsons was on the air before Seinfeld, but after 20 seasons and still counting, we choose to look at The Simpsons as three different shows: the early Simpsons, the 90s phenomenon Simpsons, and the present Simpsons. The 90s phenomenon version of the show is what we're talking about here. By about the mid-90s, the show started focusing less on the Bart-gets-in-trouble/Homer-chokes-him formula of its earlier seasons and became a post-modern, socially relevant piece of pop culture genius. Long before Seinfeld went off the air, The Simpsons was already "it" for the 18-24 crowd. So by the time Jerry bowed out, it was Homer who became the new king of television comedy, and The Simpsons instantly became the only sitcom left that mattered. Whether the show is still as good as it once was is certainly debatable, but there's no doubt that most of the shows on this list owe their popularity to The Simpsons in its golden age.
1. The Office (BBC) - The premise of The Office wasn't exactly pioneering. The office politics humor, the engaging love story within the comedy, the fake documentary storytelling-- they had all been done by plenty of shows and movies before. But, like alchemists, co-creators Ricky Gervais and Stephen Merchant took those elements, mixed them into an engaging story arc, and came up with the most refreshing and influential sitcom since Seinfeld.
The Office redefined the very look and feel of what could be funny on TV, managing to make laugh-out-loud comedy out of characters, dialogue and presentation that, at least according to most conventional wisdom, aren't supposed to make people laugh. First of all, watching The Office actually feels like going to work. The show never takes us very far from the beige walls and fluorescent lighting of the workplace, and since we don't know too much about who the main characters are outside of work, we tend to see them at their worst: irritable, selfish, petty and boring. The dialogue is anything but snappy; the awkward silences after a gaffe by Gervais's David Brent can be excruciating. But, despite all that, it's hard not to see The Office's influence in other shows like Arrested Development, 30 Rock or My Name is Earl. The Office popularized using film-style camerawork and doing away with the laugh track, and since then it's become the de facto signature of a "cutting edge" comedy.
So why all this for a show with a depressing setting, unsympathetic characters and clumsy dialogue? The reason BBC's The Office is so funny is because of how keenly it manages to balance the tightrope between comedy and tragedy. It's like listening to your friend tell you an embarrassing story: the only reason you're laughing is because it didn't happen to you.
I have to agree! I love the office, but some of the shows you talked about I have never heard of!? Guess I'll have to get HBO and check them out. Is the office on BBC different then the office on NBC? Is that why it go the #1 and the #6 spot?
ReplyDeleteI found this to be very entertaining and incredibly accurate. I enjoy every one of these shows. You have good taste.
ReplyDelete